Stock is up 4% after hours. I'm not sure which "wall street" strawman you are attacking, but it doesn't appear to be the one that actually trades stock.
ok, my criticism is directed towards Wall St analysts. I could be wrong but it feels like the vast majority of them see X as a money pit that's hampering Alphabet as whole. I've been hearing this for about a year now. If ad revenue wasn't up, the chorus would be louder.
I also don't know if that's entirely true either. After the earnings came out, it looks like quite a few Wall St analysts changed their recommendation to outperform, with a target price of 900+, and in general, it seems like many analysts all have pretty high target prices assigned to Alphabet.