Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mcbits 3628 days ago
It's starting to seem like they had these lists made up ahead of time and have been waiting for the right time to start cleansing the ranks.
5 comments

> It's starting to seem like they had these lists made up ahead of time and have been waiting for the right time to start cleansing the ranks.

Kind of how the 342-page US Patriot Act was introduced days after the September 11th terrorist attacks?

According to Wikipedia's entry on the Patriot Act, it was introduced on October 23. Over a month to produce 342 pages of double-spaced federal legalese? Probably not incredible. That said, I'm sure the TLA agencies took advantage of the crisis to "suggest" a lot of things they'd been wanting.
Aside from what the others said, the PATRIOT ACT (it's all an acronym) was based on an older bill that was not passed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Counterterrorism_Act_o...

http://www.wnyc.org/story/whats-bill/

You mean weeks after, right? Because it was weeks after, not days after. Good story though.
> It's starting to seem like they had these lists made up ahead of time and have been waiting for the right time to start cleansing the ranks.

That much is obvious. Erdogan didn't start laying blame for problems on the "parallel structure" only after the coup attempt, he's been doing it for years. The coup attempt provided the political pretext for stronger action against the group (and, potentially, others that the regime can use the pretext of going after the group to deal with at the same time) than the regime thought it could get away with before.

Governments frequently use crises as pretexts for actions which they wanted to do previously but didn't find political support for, both against specific internal or external targets and in terms of general, non-specifically-targeted policy.

It's likely par for the course to have lists of potential adversaries maintained in the event of a national emergency : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rex_84
This is exactly what's going on. As bad as the putsch is, in the end the wrong guy is in power if you value democracy and freedom of religion.
It's possible the coup was staged as an excuse to purge the opposition and seize more power.

Edit: changed "quite likely" to "possible" to address valid criticism.

In my book, "quite likely" would be, say, 80-90 %. And that is absurd.

It is imaginable that the coup was staged, but it is not more likely than the other, more realistic explanations. In fact, it is still rather unlikely, even if one cannot rule it out completely.

That being said, as another commentator mentioned: These lists have existed before, since tensions have been going on for years. So now Erdogan just had to pull them out of the drawer.

Agreed. There are 3 possible options in my view, and any of them could be true. There just isn't enough evidence for any of them to be likely.
Starting? That was clear when they purged the first few thousand.
Yes, "starting" may be too charitable, but the first few thousand were military, so it was at least plausible that they were tagged for actual involvement with the coup.
The first group were Judges actually.