Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by NhanH 3628 days ago
> I have received lots of "free" stuff and welfare along the way, both for nothing and for the promise of educating myself. The first is dead wrong, the second is the deal breaker to me.

Why is getting welfare for the promising of educating yourself a deal breaker for you?

1 comments

First, let me admit that I might have not picked the right words above. To me, the best money/welfare that I ever got, were the scholarships. Just a little money that were exclusively intended to be spent on education.

This brings my thoughts to the second and more important aspect of the labor market. Recently there was an article here about Spain and how it had 5 million unemployed people and still the economy lacked the needed workers. And what's the response of the socialists there? Give more welfare to the people. That's just not adequate. They are hoping that the people will educate themselves but let's just see how that would develop and just few percent of them will study and fill in the labor gap. Governments should seek and demand from the people to study in exchange for that welfare money.

Last point may be only that education is highly correlated with the income and breaking out of poverty, but that's something we all know. And besides education, what else can welfare do to help you find a job?

P.S. I hope I am not the only one who is totally disregarding the claim that automation will eat out all the jobs. There has been written so much about this and we all know the problem is not there is less business to do nowadays, the problem is is harder to find the qualified workers.

That discussion about Spain's labour market also had many arguments along the lines of the pay being far too low. It's not that monodimensional of a problem, especially considering we have a free labour market in Europe, and Spain has good climate and nice people. However, many who do study change country and work somewhere else, which you can't really stop with your plan.
What are the schools like in Spain? Do people need to leave to study?
Not particularly bad, afaik. They leave after they studied, because now they're qualified to get good jobs in Germany or the Netherlands.