Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mcguire 3642 days ago
"There weren't a more racist and savage group in ww2 than the allied soldier in the pacific."

Not even the German government, engaged in attempting to exterminate the undesirable population of Europe? Or the German treatment of Soviet prisoners? Or Soviets of German prisoners?

Certainly, there was a lot of hatred and racism on the Allied side. (And then there the allegation of Patton's famous disinclination to accept the surrender of German soldiers who had just fired single-use anti-tank weapons at American forces.) But I think you're getting hyperbolic there.

Do you have a source for the hundreds of thousands of Japanese soldiers being tortured, mutilated, decapitated, and turned into war trophies?

1 comments

> Not even the German government, engaged in attempting to exterminate the undesirable population of Europe?

They weren't more racist than the US/British. You could argue they were as racist since they modeled their racial ideology from the US/Britain.

> Or the German treatment of Soviet prisoners?

The german treatment of soviets and the soviet treatment of the germans were horrific. But nowhere close to the level of depravity that the allies in the pacific sunk to. The allies didn't just kill japanese POWs. The allies tortured and mutilated and decapitated hundreds of thousands of japanese soldiers. There are countless japanese skulls and all kinds of mutilated japanese body parts in the US because the GIs did so much mutilating in the pacific. No fighting force in ww2 engaged in such disgusting behavior.

> Do you have a source for the hundreds of thousands of Japanese soldiers being tortured, mutilated, decapitated, and turned into war trophies?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_mutilation_of_Japanes...

It was so prevalent that LIFE magazine ran a cover story on it...

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b5/LIFE_May_1944...

It was so prevalent that FDR, the leader of the free world, was fiddling with the bones of a tortured japanese soldier in the oval office.

"On June 13, 1944, the press reported that President Roosevelt had been presented with a letter-opener made out of a Japanese soldier's arm bone by Francis E. Walter, a Democratic congressman.[4] Supposedly, the president commented, "This is the sort of gift I like to get", and "There'll be plenty more such gifts"

"In 1984, Japanese soldiers' remains were repatriated from the Mariana Islands. Roughly 60 percent were missing their skulls"

More than 70,000 japanese were killed in marina. If 60% were missing their skulls, that means more than 42,000 skulls sent to the US. That's just one island campaign...

You don't learn about this in school. As I said, evil won ww2 and evil lost ww2. There was no good guy in ww2.