Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thrkw123456789 3653 days ago
No the uk has no direct democracy. Parliament is sovereign not the electorate. Indeed before any referendum the uk parliament has to pass specific legislation binding itself to the result+. These petitions are a relatively new thing and have never (please someone jump in and correct me if I'm wrong) lead to anything meaningful. 100,000 signatures mean that it has to be considered for a discussion in parliament - it doesn't even mean the discussion has to go ahead and if it does a vote in parliament may not happen (filibustering happens on non-goverment initiated debates in parliament) and would not be binding anyway.

+ interestingly the EU referendum was technically only advisory - but parliament would be mad to ignore it.

2 comments

The apology made by Gordon Brown to Alan Turing was prompted by a petition

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/sep/11/pm-apology-to-...

A complete list that were debated is at https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions?state=debated

These petitions are a relatively new thing and have never (please someone jump in and correct me if I'm wrong) lead to anything meaningful.

For a very small value of "meaningful", I signed a petition when the government made suggestions they would be moving businesses to submitting tax returns four times a year. The response was not actually a change in policy but a pretty good explanation of the miscommunication over what they were actually planning to do and why it wasn't worth getting worried about. So at least as a way to get the government to explain their intentions more clearly, it worked.