[argonaut]

Let me elaborate. It is easy easy easy to nitpick and find holes in someone's proposals, someone's problem statements, and someone's goals in life.

Statements are adding noise and less than nothing of value if they just consist of telling people they are working on the wrong thing... and not proceeding to tell them what they should instead be working on, and giving clear positive reasons why (instead of negative reasons someone should not be working on something).

Incidentally this is a broader problem with HN discourse.