Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by abraham_s 3670 days ago
1) This is highly dependent on the place. In rural areas or smaller towns, there is high probability that someone will take you to the hospital.

2) There is no equivalent of 911 in India. You can call the police but they usually don't have ambulances. Most cases you will have to take the injured in a private vehicle to the hospital.

3) Harassment by police is a real thing in many places. They will suspect you of being involved in the accident. At least in my state (Kerala) there has been conscious effort to resolve this and seems to be working.

4) There is government hospitals who will treat you, no questions asked. But these are not present everywhere, and many don't have adequate resources (Operation theaters, Intensive Care Units etc) in many of these. So there is a chance that you will have to travel to bigger hospital to get appropriate care.

Anecdote. Few years back , I was driving to my home when police flagged me down and asked me to take a lady injured (she was pillion-riding on a two wheeler) to the hospital. Took then to fairly large government hospital (which is also a medical college). The attending doctor asked me whether I was involved in the accident and the told me I can leave. I informed the relatives of the injured (got numbers from her companion) and left.

1 comments

Real naive question time, sorry ahead of time - are the police as corrupt as they're portrayed to be in western media? Bribes requested constantly, that sort of thing?
Short answer is yes. Long answer is that it is that the level of corruption varies from place to place but the police susceptible to political influence everywhere. A daily interaction with the cops like a traffic stop can be similar to one in US , cop checks your documentation and issues a citation, or it can be “indian” one where he accuses you of a crime (that you have committed or not), gives a option of pay him x amount as bribe or paying a fine of 5x.

There are many honest policemen/women (as well as dishonest ones) but if you are pitted against someone well-connected politically or rich or (usually) both then chances are police is going to side with them and you will probably lose regardless of who is guilty. Unless something extraordinary happens,like you get showcased in the media.

It is not only police. The government machinery on the lowest level is inefficient and corrupt. You need to pay a bribe to get a power connection to your home, a drivers license etc. If you refuse to do so, you will be forced to spent your time in following up, complaining to superiors. It is doable to some extent but you will spent significant amount of your time and energy.

This is my experience in one of the better states in India, which makes me wonder about the rest of the country.

If you have done mistake and need to escape yes bribe is relevant or you want something to happen faster again yes otherwise mostly if you are not in hurry or did not do anything wrong mostly need not pay anything. SOme police may still ask you to buy him a coffee or 50 to 500 rupees depending on ur urgency and his tightness
On average yes. There's massive corruption.

Source - I live here