Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by prajjwal 3662 days ago
As someone who has been using OTR/DuckDuckGo as my primary chat server since early 2014, I would recommend against it.

When it goes down, it goes down for multiple days, even a week. Prolonged outages have happened twice or thrice in the last two years, with no helpful messages from the staff. Heck, they didn't even bother announcing the outage before I posted on their community forums.

Their server stopped pushing offline messages to clients a long time ago. People complained, it still doesn't work on my end.

They said they would look into creating a status page, but we still can't tell during an outage if they know about it or not.

The bottom line is that maintaining their XMPP server is simply not a priority for them.

You should look into other providers that use better servers, and are also interested in maintaining their node.

EDIT: I'm basically asking you people to recommend a better XMPP node, somewhere you've personally had a good experience over a long period of time.

1 comments

I can confirm that sadly - this exactly mirrors my own experiences with DDG XMPP. Sometimes for entire weeks I have been what looked like the only person reporting (or caring) that the XMPP servers are down (mind you that this was years ago, I can't comment on the current state of things), sometimes followed with reactions like "Oh, right... We've restarted the server, see if it works for you." at which point I gave up and moved to a self-hosted ejabberd ever since.

While nowadays most of my contacts are on private XMPP servers, I remember few having some reasonably solid experiences with https://jabber.at/ (can be also found at https://xmpp.zone/ for a better sounding domain name, which I guess matters to people who hate the now obsolete "Jabber" term). Can't from my personal experience vouch for a "good for a long period of time", but if someone is looking for at least a well established server, this should be as good start as any. Also, the news page shows they're quite serious about server updates and transparent, which is a big thumb up in my eyes.

Edit: typos