Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wtbob 3677 days ago
> high-speed internet and cell service are seen as luxuries and not basic infrastructure

I would never want to live without high-speed mobile Internet (which can provide the equivalent of cell service), but is it really a necessity to live? I was a boy before cell phones even existed, and anyone outside academia and a few tech companies had the Internet, and life was fine.

It's certainly extremely convenient, but I don't think it's a necessity.

> plus some who believe that the poor ought to be excluded from using basic infrastructure anyway

Do you have evidence for that statement?
4 comments
Sreekar911 3677 days ago
Even more previous generations' people would make the same argument: "Is telephone really a necessity? We lived without telephones and we were fine, our life was fine" and so on. Replace telephone with telegram or a car for even earlier generations.

Now the problem with this argument is that we're not living in that generation. We're living in the present generation, where a decent, if not high speed internet is absolutely essential in order to progress. Can you still live without internet in the present generation? Sure. But is there a remote chance that such life would be comfortable and painless? Absolutely not. Not even a chance.

link
nickpsecurity 3677 days ago
I hear you but you can counter-claim it easily for high-speed Internet for business. Just look at how critical the Internet is to all kinds of firms these days. Even those that mostly don't need the Internet often have an expensive, leased line for main HQ. There's also the meme of traveling salespeople and such who benefit from higher speeds.

So, with so much dependence, it stands to reason a country's businesses can be a bit more competitive and efficient if they have high-speed, low-cost Internet. The Internet part is necessary for most even if other attributes aren't. They're certainly useful, though, as they increase capabilities and profit simultaneously.

link
freen 3677 days ago
From 2011: 80% of fortune 500 jobs accept only online applications.

http://2010-2014.commerce.gov/blog/2011/12/30/look-ahead-201...

link
setpatchaddress 3677 days ago
Do you consider basic telephone service a necessity?
link