Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by albeva 3694 days ago
Slow, sluggish, resource hungry and looks alien everywhere. Yeah right. Progress ... If there is one thing its done is lower standard for native applications everywhere.
4 comments

As someone above said, they have achieved what Java/Swing set out to do in the 90s.
Just like websites. They'll never succeed. /s
Just because something is "succeeding" it doesn't mean it's not bads qualitywise or it provides a good experience.

(Case in point - Windows Vista :P )

Quality of implementation has some correlation with market success, but ultimately there are many variables involved.

Just the other day someone had detailed that they have a business based on Delphi with some ancient database. Can't be rewritten, but it brings in revenue.

> Just the other day someone had detailed that they have a business based on Delphi with some ancient database. Can't be rewritten, but it brings in revenue.

And quality-wise it's probably better than any alternative "cloud-based" solution they could buy these days.

Websites don't take up 30+ MB disk and 100+ MB RAM (well, not in Firefox anyway, and that's another thing Electron is missing: switchable runtimes and rendering engines, unlike the web)
In a way, Electron is web enabled as a web browser and very stable across platform. Native application might not be 100% reliable.
it's better to have a slow app out for users than having no app at all.
Depends, it might prevent somebody from building a proper app because the slow one is "good enough".
Spoken like a true assembly programmer.
Yeah, because Facebook/WhatsApp can't afford a native desktop client.