Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by F2468 3689 days ago
If there was anything resembling free market capitalism, phone prices would not be $10/min...
3 comments

You're confusing free market capitalism with "perfectly competitive market".

Nowhere in the study of economics does it say that free market capitalism necessarily leads to all industries having multiple competing companies that drive prices down.

On a somewhat unrelated note, if history and human nature is any indicator, then we know that with an under-regulated market most industries will gravitate towards oligopolies with homogeneous product offerings, monopolies or cartels (colluding oligopolies)

Well, in DC policy circles, the presumed arbiter of what constitutes "free markets" or "economic freedom":

http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking

Is very much in favor of private prisons (and, consequently, $10/min phone calls):

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1988/05/bg650-a-gui...

> the presumed arbiter of what constitutes "free markets" or "economic freedom"

This assumption is ludicrous. I can't even imagine the thought process that would lead you to think that that makes any sense. Being the loudest proponent of your vision of a concept doesn't make you a good arbiter of what constitutes it: in fact it makes you a terrible one.

Not that I have as low an opinion of Heritage as I do of them, but do you think the Westboro Baptist Church is the "presumed arbiter" of what constitutes Christianity, simply because they shout the loudest about God?

Westboro are not taken seriously in DC policy circles. Heritage are taken very seriously.
I wonder if their view has changed over the almost 30 years since that research report was published.
If anything they seem to have gotten more rabid:

http://www.heritage.org/research/commentary/2000/10/the-left...

I wonder if their viewpoint has changed since the more than decade and a half since that article was published. Is it that hard to find something current if it's so fundamental to your argument?
A prison is not a free market, its by definition a place administered and controlled by an entity in order to restrict the liberties of those imprisoned there.