Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ryanlol 3701 days ago
>and for sure has been used in recent years against other folks of the Tor community.

Examples?

Edit: Not really sure why asking for examples gets downvotes. Google news search definitely didn't turn up anything but this story.
2 comments
Bartweiss 3701 days ago
If you'll count "people running exit nodes" in "community", it's fairly common. People get searched and possibly charged for whatever is coming out of their node, but not convicted since its not their traffic.

And yes, that could be the legal system working normally, but there have been cases where the government already knows about the exit node, but doesn't reveal that information to the judge while obtaining a warrant.

link
ryanl0l 3701 days ago
I'm aware of exit nodes as I've myself been subject to such attention, but I don't think that really fits chinathrows description.
link
chinathrow 3701 days ago
http://www.dw.com/en/snowden-ally-appelbaum-claims-his-berli...
link
maze-le 3701 days ago
What really worries me about this story is the following question: Are german agencies involved in this? I mean, assume the break ins are real, can the FBI operate in a foreign country without consent? At least they should know it and did nothing to stop it... Or am I msitaken here somewhere?
link
MacsHeadroom 3701 days ago
>can the FBI operate in a foreign country

What do you think embassies are for?

It seems likely that Germany was cooperative, at the least. But they needn't be. These are spies we're talking about, afterall.

link
maze-le 3701 days ago
I always was under the assumption, that the FBI is a police-force, not a spy-agency (like the CIA or NSA). I kind of realize that the difference is getting smaller in recent years.

There is good reason to keep them (Police and Intelligence) separated, in germany we call this 'Trennungsgebot', this is a direct historical consequence of the Gestapo.

So, technically, is the FBI a police or an intelligence agency?

link
MacsHeadroom 3701 days ago
The FBI is an investigative law enforcement agency. So, I would say that they are intended to be both.

The CIA, a "pure" intelligence agency, has been competing with the FBI for decades, leading to the FBI becoming more and more of an intelligence agency over time (in addition to their law enforcement "police" activities).

Yes, the line continues to blur.

link