Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tchow 3715 days ago
wow, that microphone array you linked costs USD$750! Are there any cheaper alternatives?
3 comments

Not that I've found yet, but the actual hardware on that board costs something like $10-15, so someone could easily make one.

The high price is because it's a development board. (I think it's a silly to price development boards highly, but it is very common.)

I hope a chinese manufacturer makes one soon. The teardown for Echo had the parts for a bit more than that, but you could do it cheaper, multichannel ADC and half a dozen MEMS mics. I guess drivers would be the time consuming bit
The board actually doesn't appear to have an ADC, the microphones output pulse density encoded digital data wich can be directly received and interpreted by the processor.
I'm curious, how would you recommend they be priced?
Every comment that starts with "curious" seem to be spam on HN. Is this always the same guy or a bot? Almost every HN topic contains one of these "curious" comments...
It's a common English idiom, but even though I've been here over twice as long as your account date I can't say I've noticed an infestation of "curious" comments... though given curiosity is a hacker virtue, perhaps it's not surprising there may be more of it here? I still am genuinely curious how GGP would have dev boards priced instead -- the market is pretty much limited to students (the ones at good schools have the schools pay for the boards, or the schools get discounts) or professionals (who again expense through their company), what's the incentive to lower prices?
Xmos mainly sells development kits to showcase their chips - that's why they're that expensive.
I think the Microsoft Kinect comes with a Microphone Array.
PS3 Eye too, 4 microphones AFAIK. Those had a big discount on Amazon recently.

EDIT: Still are, 5 bucks.

http://www.amazon.com/PlayStation-Eye-3/dp/B000VTQ3LU

I've got one knocking about in the drawer. Let me know if you get beamforming working on it. I think there are multi channel audio drivers for Linux/RPi for PS3 Eye
Welp, looks like I just bought 3, haha! Thanks!
Yes Kinect has an array of 4 mics and can do audio beam forming. Plus there's a terrific SDK for Windows.
I said it in a thread about the Kinect - I think it's only 135 (ish) degrees of reception, and sometimes it can be more finicky than that.

I'd love to get my hands on an open source array.