[bitdivision]

I might be missing something here but if they still track the last page read, then why would it incentivize click-bait titles and synopses?

Additionally, I think your first two points mostly address the outliers on the bell curve.

It seems to me that GP's solution would be at least somewhat more fair than the current system although its certainly not perfect.

[kbenson]

> I might be missing something here but if they still track the last page read, then why would it incentivize click-bait titles and synopses?

It's much easier to make a book sound epic, insightful and/or wonderful than it is to actually write something like that. It might take a while for the user to give up, but who cares if people only get 50-100 pages into your book before quitting if you can attract multiple times more people?

> Additionally, I think you're first two points mostly address the outliers on the bell curve.

I have personally alternated between those extremes in the last six months. I've read multiple thousands of pages one month, and been too busy to read anything the next. I also suspect there's a population of people that will sign up and forget about it for long periods - just like gym memberships.

[bitdivision]

> It's much easier to make a book sound epic, insightful and/or wonderful than it is to actually write something like that. It might take a while for the user to give up, but who cares if people only get 50-100 pages into your book before quitting if you can attract multiple times more people?

I don't see how that is any different with a per-user pot than the current system?

[kbenson]

The major difference is that it may force the current scam which seems to rely partially on getting people to download and click the last page and partially on a scammer network to do this for each other to move entirely to scamming real people to click the last page.

That said, that's not a good reason in my mind, since we shouldn't be afraid of stopping abuse just because we are afraid it will shift to another area, as it's still progress. I retract that specific example (but I think the others are worth thinking about).