[zaroth]

URL based Bitcoin wallets proved this not to be the case. URLs get picked up by Omnibar, Skype, etc. they find their way into search results... I wouldn't even trust secret material in the fragment-id even though that in theory is safer.

[ikeboy]

Doesn't excluding them in robots.txt solve the search engine problem?

[_Understated_]

Following the rules laid out in a robots.txt file is optional. The reputable search engines tend to play by the rules but dodgy ones? Not so sure.

[ikeboy]

The dodgy ones don't have access to the URLs. The example was Skype links: if Microsoft scrapes those, they'll follow the rules and not make them available in searches.

If you give your link to a dodgy search engine, you've lost.