Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by TranquilMarmot 3725 days ago
From hjson.org:

"YAML expresses structure through whitespace. Significant whitespace is a common source of mistakes that we shouldn't have to deal with."
1 comments
jholman 3725 days ago
Okay, does anyone actually believe that causes a problem?

I can think of ONE time when that causes a problem, and that's with indentation with multi-line strings. Oh look, HJSON included that feature. That's like throwing the baby out and keeping all the bathwater.

link
gboone42 3725 days ago
I can't find a specific example off the top of my head but I'll say I've been managing a Jekyll site for a while now and whitespace errors in frontmatter and data files cause all kinds of problems. I'm not sure I could explain the details but it's a legit criticism of YAML. IMO part of the problem is that YAML looks very straightfowrard and is until it suddenly isn't. Whitespace is part of that problem.
link
kaishiro 3725 days ago
As an anecdote on the flip side, I've been building Middleman sites for a while now and can't remember ever having an issue with whitespace in the front matter or local data.
link
BobTheCoder 3725 days ago
Yeah I'm with you. Developers should have no problem dealing with whitespace and the result is you get a easier to read format.

Although admittedly I haven't had to work with YAML a lot but I have liked it when i've touched it.

link