Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by recursive 3729 days ago
> The key is F major.

Where is this coming from? It's pretty clearly G minor to me. The bass is playing G. The main phrase starts and ends on a G.

> This 1.334 is a ratio of adding 5 semitones in hertz. This should sound like this.

This harmonic overtone kills it for me. I know there are some overtones in the original, but not like this. 5 semi-tones is an interval of a perfect fourth. I think maybe a perfect fifth would work (7 semi-tones) but this overtone pretty much destroys it for me.

1 comments

Hi, post author here. Thanks for pointing out!

I know it's wrong and working on these improvements:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Clojure/comments/4dl454/recreating_...

Cool. Those changes sound pretty dead-on.
Applied the corrections, check the sound now :)
It sounds like a much better approximation than before. Thanks.