[smitherfield]

Thanks for the info, and for the very clear explanation!

Obviously, even in C the memory management is a high-level runtime abstraction of sorts (neither the programmer nor the compiler is choosing the actual addresses in memory to alloc/dealloc), so at what point on the continuum of C++-style RAII, Obj-C RC, Swift ARC and so on would you say "garbage collection" comes into play? Is it just one of those "I know it when I see it" type things?

[steveklabnik]

Any time :)

So, one of the reasons this is a bit muddy is that historically speaking, it was much more clear. You had languages which did some kind of "automatic" memory management, if that was through a refcount system of some kind (Like Python was (is?)), or a tracing GC (like Lisp was/is, or Ruby, whatever). And then you had languages which had some sort of "manual" memory management, where you explicitly allocate and free heap memory. I think that the real distinction here is "does runtime state decide if something gets deallocated"? If so, then that's garbage collected. If not, then it's "manual".

But languages like Rust and Swift sort of bend this, and I see them as coming from each side, looking in. So Swift is like a GC'd language that's not _quite_ GC'd, while Rust is like a manually managed language that's not _quite_ manually managed. They feel a bit different.

[smitherfield]

Thanks again; very interesting stuff, and I feel like my understanding of the concept here is quite a bit better now. It'd make a good blog post, I think. (I'm probably the only person seeing this convo).

It's a great skill to be able to explain pretty complex topics in "layman's" terms; I don't think I'm alone in having the experience of posing a question to an expert, getting a jargon-heavy answer that takes 30min of Googling to parse (or a condescending one that assumes I'm unfamiliar with basic CS concepts), and left feeling foolish for asking. So kudos to you! :)

[steveklabnik]

Thanks! I've worked very hard at it; it's why my job is docs :) Have a great night (or whatever your time zone is)!

[smitherfield]

Good guess; EDT here/Boston. :) You too!

[steveklabnik]

Brooklyn here. I may show up at the Boston Rust meetup over the next few months!