[oahziur]

We used PR based review before, but we found it is hard and inefficient when many changes are required. Its hard to see whether comments is being addressed in Bitbucket PR. We switched to Phabricator recently, and the incremental reviews really helps.

I think you can go over your previous PRs, and see how many of them has multiple rounds of reviews. If most of them are minor changes/fixes, then switching maybe unnecessary.

[Xelank]

Thanks for your input. There definitely is a lot of back and forth and I consider it a very good thing. It's interesting because it's a chicken-and-egg problem - if your tool is painful to use, then team members are less likely to participate seriously.

(What I'm really wondering though is whether incremental code reviews are specific to the pre-commit model. In theory I don't think this is the case since tools like Upsource has it as well)

Anyway, what was your experience migrating the team to Phabricator? What's the general workflow from starting a new feature to getting it to prod? Cheers