That is a difficult problem to solve. How do you differentiate between genuine (even if self-interested) self expression and 'advertisement'?
If I think I make really muffins and I want everyone to know is that advertisement and is it a bad thing? Of course, I love my muffins so much that I want everyone to have them so I'm going to have to start charging, because the best way to get as many people to try them is to do it full time. And of course at some point I'm going to have to hire other people and teach them to make the muffins for me because one man can only make so many muffins. I'll probably have to incorporate and buy a muffin factory. And I'm much better with muffins than I am with words so actually the proclamations of my muffin's superiority are going to be designed by a professional.
I actually don't have a way with words so I'm not sure how to wrap this up but it's a piece of my perspective either way.
IMO, simply flat out preventing for profit companies from talking with non customers is probably worth it. Sure, you might end up with some edge cases, but in the end customers pay for advertising and it's often zero or even negative sum.
The edge case is of course. Disease X now has a treatment!
But IMO, if it's important people are going to find out other ways.
When an "infection" from an ad can lead to malware, trojans, ransomware, etc...
At what point does the monetary value of the damages caused by "advertising" surpass the amount of damages caused by cigs?
Will that amount of damage ever be more than lung cancer and lost lives? Who knows... but ads aren't just annoying. They are dangerous.
Just ask the hospitals that have had to run at limited capacity due to infections. (that infection was due to a tainted email... but it could have easily been from a drive-by-ad-malware... ala 30-after-30 malware: http://www.engadget.com/2016/01/08/you-say-advertising-i-say... ). And it's only a matter of time until one infection causes a death...
Then expand that to our increasingly connected cars and houses...
I don't want to eat fast-food, but they will use shiny pictures, bright colors, reverse psychology, "everyone else eat burgers" tactics, etc. to make me want it.
"Decision fatigue can influence irrational impulse purchases at supermarkets. During a trip to the supermarket, trade-off decisions regarding prices and promotions can produce decision fatigue, hence by the time the shopper reaches the cash register, less willpower remains to resist impulse purchases of candy and sugared items."
We are bombarded with ads, which we discard, but every time we discard one, it tires us.
When I read that sort of thing i'd like I'm reliving the 1980s, where everyone had that sort of "they live" (the movie) paranoia that they were being controlled.
You can easily transcend all of that.
Not the fact that you're being controlled by an elite consisting of rich, well brought up white people and a media which serves them and each other.
But the day to day annoyances of adverts and supermarket deals etc. If you read books, listen to music ripped from CDs, watch movies/tvs from netflix/downloads etc, then you're going to suffer only very slight interference from ads. Certainly I see no justification for the suggestion it's "tiring" to "discard" an ad.
If you have to shop in supermakets (and you do not) then it's possible to just buy sensible stuff; fruit, veg, milk, juice, break, rice etc. You don't need to wander down the colourful aisles and pay over the odds for this seasons exciting "as seen on tv" junk foods. It's hard to imagine any self-respecting HN reading struggling to understand which size/brand of some product is the cheapest. It's not remotely taxing to do this, and mental activity keeps your mind fit and staves off dementia. It has no consequence on willpower whatsoever. In any event, a lot of shops in the UK have no "candy" by the "cash register" because it annoys parents who have to get their kids to stop screaming for it.
When we fully understand the psychological effects of advertisements on the brain like we do the physical effects of cigarettes on the lungs. IMO a pretty long time.
If I think I make really muffins and I want everyone to know is that advertisement and is it a bad thing? Of course, I love my muffins so much that I want everyone to have them so I'm going to have to start charging, because the best way to get as many people to try them is to do it full time. And of course at some point I'm going to have to hire other people and teach them to make the muffins for me because one man can only make so many muffins. I'll probably have to incorporate and buy a muffin factory. And I'm much better with muffins than I am with words so actually the proclamations of my muffin's superiority are going to be designed by a professional.
I actually don't have a way with words so I'm not sure how to wrap this up but it's a piece of my perspective either way.