Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by showerst 3741 days ago
Feeling the pain here too. What DNS providers do others use and like? Route53?
6 comments

The sites I have that are actually up right now are those routed through CloudFlare.
Route53 is hard not to love; simple to develop against and very very reliable.

I wrap it in git to make updates more straightforward for people unfamiliar with AWS, but even using it directly is very simple from multiple languages. (https://dns-api.com/)

This has always been a good resource to see who the front runners are: http://www.solvedns.com/dns-comparison/
Bind, running on VMs. Not hard.
You run your own authoritative DNS servers?
I ran my non-authoritative DNS server [bind] on a droplet for about a year. But the server crashed every few months. Why? Never figured out. A restart always fixed it.

Later shifted to DO's DNS servers.

Now that that one is down too, just shifted back to domain register's DNS.

Everything is working now.

Where I work we use Rotue53. For my personal domains I just use my registrar, Namecheap.
For us, Route53 is painful. We host a few thousand zones, and due to rate limiting on APIs, doing something like "Show a list of domain names" or "Give all the domains matching some pattern" were particularly painful. Upwards of 30 seconds to do a simple list of domains meant we were forced to cache locally. A local cache, combined with the fact that zone names are not unique in their system (possible to create multiple abc.com entries, which differ only in an internal id and the list of NS entries) made it hard to ensure that our internal systems matched "reality". Then the administrative nightmare of 3-4 different NS entries for each zone means customized, rather than generic, instructions for validating NS settings at the individual registrars.

All in all, it was not a fun experience with such a large volume of zones, but we knew we were an edge case.

You can contact amazon to get rate limits increased if you have the use case
dnsmadeeasy for around 8 years now