Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by seddona 3745 days ago
Great work, would love to try this out but I'm not going to link my Facebook to a random app.
2 comments

Facebook will tell you what the app has access to before you give it permission. I tried it, and it only has access to your public profile information, which is already publicly available anyway.
Yea, but before there was nothing easy to tie this app and the public profile. Now there's no choice but to tie the two.
What are you attempting to avoid? What's the risk that you're trying to mitigate? Were you planning on signing up with an anonymous email?
I wasn't planning on signing up at all—to my knowledge, nothing about this single-page-app requires a session at all.

The risk here is that I don't want the app creator to know my name. It's that simple—I don't know them, I don't trust them, I trust them less now that they ask for completely unnecessary information. Let's say traffic to this site is linked with lower credit scores: it's naturally absurd that the two are causally related, but it's a reality that I have zero control over how my traffic data relates to how companies use it. All I can do is reduce my traffic data from getting into their hands where I can help it.

>nothing about this single-page-app requires a session at all.

The app saves you the gifs you like/disliked that requires a session. Now you could say the app doesn't have to save that information, but then I'd say it's a toy app so it doesn't have to do anything. The creator wanted it to save your history, therefore it requires a session.

Let's say it requires a regular email login instead of facebook (in order to support password reset). If you're using an anonymous email that you've been careful never to accidentally associate with your name, then yeah you could keep the app creator from knowing your name.

If like most people you just use your regular email address, it's trivial to get your name with a quick google search.

>Let's say traffic to this site is linked with lower credit scores

If you're really worried about that, then you should probably have an entire fake virtual identity to handle things like this.

> then you should probably have an entire fake virtual identity to handle things like this.

I don't believe facebook allows this. Hence the problem with a facebook-only login.

As a non-facebook user, I would enjoy just being able to try the service. Email I have so that would be enough for me and I guess a lot of other people as well.
Why would anyone want to trust their precious personal information including real name, photograph, and friend list to some random guy from the internet? Would you publish it on reddit? On NH? On shady anonymous forums?
All of that information is already public. Anyone can get it from facebook (not just your friends), why would you care if already public information gets reposted?

Also the app didn't request access to your friends list.

How would the app know which profile to look at?
you can try it out, I just added a username/password login