Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by akavi 3749 days ago
Am I really that much of an outlier in loving coffeescript?

I know a lot of people don't like the extra translation effort to debugging, and some aren't fond of significant whitespace, but I'm surprised that that's enough to make it into the top 5 most dreaded. Is there something else I'm missing?
3 comments
mavdi 3749 days ago
My reaction to CoffeeScript over time:

CoffeeScript is shit, CoffeeScript is ok, CoffeeScript is great, CoffeeScript is ok, CoffeeScript is shit

link
turbohz 3749 days ago
I would assume it got "downvoted" by JavaScript developers that had to deal with it at some point.

(I personally prefer coffeescript)

link
robocaptain 3749 days ago
Right there with you. I was generally aware (mostly from HN) that it seemed less popular than when I started using it -- but _dread_? Surprising. I really enjoy it.
link
josteink 3749 days ago
I think dread is warranted. Seeing Coffescript is enough for me to completely disregard and abandon a project I otherwise perceived interesting.
link
robocaptain 3748 days ago
Can I ask why? Just out of legitimate curiosity. I don't work with a lot of other developers.
link
josteink 3748 days ago
I think it's ugly. It introduces uncertainty about the exact semantics of statements (as in does this code really do what I think it does?). It doesn't add any capabilities which JavaScript doesn't have. It makes debugging more complex, because errors are not actually happening in the code you wrote, but code a compiler wrote based on something else.

It introduces indirection and complexity, while adding zero value. As such it's on overall a negative value proposition, and that's everything it takes for me to decide something is not worth it.

I find it a perfectly rational decision and attitude.

While I'm not a fan per se, at least other transpired languages like typescript and clojurescript at least adds new capabilities to justify the additional complexity.

link
robocaptain 3748 days ago
Definitely not calling you irrational - I really was just curious. I actually find your analysis pretty straight on. I realize now that part of the reason I like Coffeescript is because I like the way it looks! I'm more of a hobbyist, and haven't really had time to keep up with the latest developments in JavaScript, but I do understand a lot of the original reasons for CS may have been covered by the latest ES6.

Anyways, I do appreciate the response.

link