Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by laurentoget 3754 days ago
Can someone remind me why i am supposed to need an internet connection to score a piece of music?
3 comments

Your tone is snarky and shows a lack of imagination.

* No install

* Automatic software updates

* No need to back up data yourself

* Easy sharing

* Multi-user editing

* Mix and match with snippets composed by others

* Forking model

* Easy embedding on a webpage

An offline version is about to be released, and if you ask why a web-based version, it can be very useful for Chromebooks for example.
But why would someone use this instead of Finale, Sibelius, or even MuseScore or Lilypond, all of which are very much better at score editing?

It's really not hard to email someone a Sibelius (etc) file for editing, or even to work together in a session over Skype/Facetime.

I suspect the number of Chromebook owners who can't live without an online music collaboration solution isn't huge.

Things is that Finale and Sibelius are expensive. They're not very intuitive and convenient for beginners. We do not expect to come as a pro software like them.

Finally we're only 1 year old they're more than 10. Give us some time ;)

Well, you don't have to. But if you are a teacher, I can see the potential