[p01926]

So why is Microsoft fighting us.gov regarding access to data stored in another country? Isn't that, to the layman, just another variety of ribbon-wrapped box. Gates should know that, just like extra-jurisdictional data retrieval, signed malware data retrieval is dangerous, bad business and awful precedent. He must publicly set the record straight for his company's stance to have any credibility.

[simonh]

The reason Microsoft isn't releasing information stored in other countries is because doing so would break the law in those other countries. It would open Microsoft and its employees to prosecution in those countries.

I disagree with Bill on phone security and agree with Apple's stance, but even so it's pretty clear to me that Microsoft has a stronger case and literally has no choice but to deny the US DOJ access to records held abroad.

[tallanvor]

Bill Gates isn't in charge at Microsoft. Sure, he's still on the board, but he's not even the chairman anymore. It's possible that he disagrees with Microsoft fighting the government regarding access to data stored overseas, but is staying silent because he doesn't want to be seen as badmouthing current management.