Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mintplant 3782 days ago
They're rehosting loads of copyrighted content, too.
3 comments

That was pretty much how YouTube started. Content ID wasn't part of their MVP.
One key difference I see is that GIPHY is clearly either uploading or categorizing/tagging/grouping pretty obviously copyrighted stuff and is doing so under their own name "team giphy." That's a huge risk because it probably breaches the copyright safe-harbor under DMCA.

If they cut that out, they are probably fine.

Content ID was added because of the legal issues YouTube faced.
why are there no legal issues with giphy.com?
Because they're not making enough money for anyone to care yet.
If you get your business very large very quick, you can pay off settlements and regulations. This is sort of what Uber has been doing, from what I've come to understand.
Wouldn't GIF's count as original work in the IP courts? As in, the GIF is a significant change from the source so it's now a new thing.