Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by leetNightshade 3793 days ago
Switching from Java to C# doesn't offer any HUGE advantages to the end user. Switching to C++ does, granted with some drawbacks depending on how mods are handled, if they're going to be portable or not.

If Microsoft is only making a Windows version of Minecraft, then they don't have to worry about the portability of mods, which would be a shame.

1 comments

>Switching from Java to C# doesn't offer any HUGE advantages to the end user.

I know C# doesn't offer much in terms of optimization.

I was thinking they would do a C# rewrite because getting modders to switch from Java to C# is easier and it would give them a chance to show support for C# on non-Windows systems. I also think it would reduce the chance for a community split where modders continue modding the last Java versions.

I'm probably biased in favor of modding. I remember Notch mentioning most sales came from systems where modding wasn't even possible, even though I personally think modding is the greatest thing about Minecraft. That has likely biased my view on the issue.