Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by winterchil 3792 days ago
Tesla is huge in Norway because of a number of large tax advantages from income tax deductions, to free registration, etc.

That being said, they obviously wouldn't sell if they didn't work but I wouldn't look at the popularity there as endorsement of cold weather performance, other factors are at play.

1 comments

> I wouldn't look at the popularity there as endorsement of cold weather performance

Wow. So tens of thousands of highly educated people in a cold climate country aren't a good enough indicator? What would be?

>Wow. So tens of thousands of highly educated people in a cold climate country aren't a good enough indicator?

Educated people are the types of people that do a cost analysis taking into account tax incentives and choose the best value, even if cheap.

For example, Nissan Leafs are awful compared to other cars at the same sticker price and can hardly make it back and forth to work for a long commute. However, lots of people in the bay have them because:

* massive tax credits make it cheap

* it gets employees better parking at many offices

* free charging at many offices

* access to the HOV lane

To be fair he has a bit of point. If you where choosing between a $200k car that's great all year round and a $120k car that was just as good (or better) during the summer month, but worse during the winter month, how much worse would the car have to be before you decided to go for $200k car?
Educated people make choices based on all the available information, not a single facet. For example, I imagine the massive[1][2] tax breaks in Norway for Tesla vehicles might sway quite a few people.

1: http://www.ibtimes.com/tesla-owners-norway-get-134000-tax-br...

2: http://jalopnik.com/heres-why-the-tesla-model-s-is-the-1-sel...

There are at least two plausible reasons Norwegians might not be a good indicator of how cold affects Tesla performance.

1. Almost 20% of the population of Norway is in the Oslo urban area. There could be a fairly large number of people who could get by reasonably without ever having to drive outside that area, and so would be OK with it if their car's range was reduced by cold.

2. The next half dozen or so largest population centers in Norway are also in the southern part of the country, as is Oslo. It looks like the Supercharger coverage is sufficient that any trip between the top several urban areas would have access to one every 70-100 miles. This could make reduced range due to cold acceptable for many people.