[deckar01]

Is "WeakMap" really the suggested way to implement private class properties?

Using "this" as a key into a Map of private variables looks bizarre. I would rather keep my code concise than create a layer of obfuscation.

[pcwalton]

It was really hard to make truly private properties that couldn't be leaked in some way without WeakMap. If you don't need foolproof leakage, Symbols are a more convenient way to get most of the benefits of private properties. This is intentional: as I recall, the committee realized that WeakMap wasn't the most ergonomic solution and created Symbols as a more convenient, though less ironclad, alternative.

[mstade]

Additionally, symbols would have provided a neat way to implement private (and privately shared) properties, if they hadn't decided on adding the `getOwnPropertySymbols` function[1]. Bummer.

[1]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Refe...

[pcwalton]

There were other ways to leak symbols before that method was added. They were never foolproof.

[mstade]

Oh? Would love to be enlightened!