[refurb]

Flotation devices attached to the booster = extra payload

Yes, but how much extra fuel does the rocket have to carry to land? That's a ton of extra payload as well.

[ramidarigaz]

Estimates I've heard say 15% loss of payload mass for a barge landing, 30% for land.

[refurb]

What do you mean by "loss of payload mass"? If the rocket lands on a barge it has to reduce it's payload by 15%?

Any ideas why it's higher on land? Seems like it wouldn't differ that much.

[tavert]

Ascent trajectory is much different. Orbit is mostly about horizontal velocity, the altitude is just to get above the atmosphere and is the easy part. For the first stage to return to its launch site for landing, it has to cancel out all of the horizontal velocity it builds up while lifting the second stage and payload, then turn around and come back. A barge landing can use a more optimal ascent trajectory and have the first stage land several hundred kilometers away from the launch site.

[chad_oliver]

You have to accelerate the rocket back to the launchpad if you want to land on solid ground -- there's no convenient landmasses at the right distance. That takes fuel.

[refurb]

I assume the rocket is in geosynchronous orbit? Otherwise it would just be a timing issue (i.e. fire the rockets when you're over land).

[wavesum]

The booster never reaches orbit as it is on a ballistic trajectory