Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jbangert 3813 days ago
Clever idea, however keep in mind that you are trusting both your file system permissions to be sane and your kernel to enforce them correctly (I.e. Not have bugs). a lot of projects have tried to do this (i.e. SeLINUx, trusted bsd) and it turns out to be surprisingly hard to build isolation policies that are useable and practical. I think one very cool solution recently has been qubes-- it runs each application in its own, temporary VM and provides secure UI magic for file opening, clipboard, etc
2 comments

Thank you! This leans more towards the client side than the server side. It's certainly in the hackish and glitchy direction, and has no guarantees for success.

Qubes looks really interesting. I'd love to give it a try some time. I've just grown rather attached to my FreeBSD setup and this seemed like one of the ways I might be able to improve security on it.

Why does it seem like every time -sec comes up it is either "must be able to protect against state actors" or not worth doing?

Everything has bugs once you look hard enough. But this would still require more work to bypass than some random "malwaretisement" is likely to put in.