It's ok for the poor to 'give up their' liberty by using crappy free internet in the same way it's ok for me to 'give up my liberty' by watching crappy free TV. It's not perfect but it's not the end of the world either.
Though the Indian situation isn't really like that, being charged for access to certain services. It's more crappy internet for $0/month or open access for like $5/month. I'm not convinced banning the $0 option helps the people you take that choice from.