Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by TheCartographer 3828 days ago
No, you are wrong here. All machines get old and wear out; digital machines wear out faster than mechanical ones. The OP you are replying to had a good point - capacitors in particular have a limited lifespan, and electronics are fragile. When the physical lifespan of 99% of the internals is 2-3 years before attrition in whatever it's form claims at least one component, why engineer something that cost 4x more but is only twice as rugged?

You seem to be hung up on Moore's law as well. And while Moore's law has lost some of its teeth in recent years(and tricks like cluster computing and specialized designs are staving off some of its effects), hardware still grows old quickly. (And bitching about your 5 year old $1k hardware is hilarious to those of us who remember paying $5-8k or more for "all the computer you will ever need" only to see it become almost entirely obsolete in less than a year.

But the fact is this: your 5 year old etch-a-sketch only has 256mb ram on which to run its OS and apps. Considering what people expect out of a tablet these days by way of web browsing, multitasking, etc, your iPad 1.0 actually IS obsolete, or quickly will be.

As to open sourcing the design - why in the world would Apple open source the trade secret that literally makes it Apple? The fact that Apple built it and no one else does is literally what makes Apple all of those earnings.

1 comments

My 5yo netbook is no etchasketch. Without getting into OS debates, this "old" machine boots up and gets my presentation to the projector faster than any off-the-shelf apple/MS machine. 5years is nothing for a digital machine. Capacitors can and do last far longer. They cost pennies, not even, fractions of pennies. If iPads are failing because of such fundamental components then apple has questions to answer.

256mb belongs in the 90s, not 2010. This machine came with 1gb and upgraded a couple years ago with a ssd and 4gb of memory. And anyone who travels will tell you that having an oldschool VGA output is very useful. The average conference-hall projector is far older than the average portable. One less adapter is one less thing to loose.

You don't have to "open source" designs. Look at what car companies do. They maintain a supply of spares and they license out designs they don't want to build themselves. That's what people expect from car companies.

Throwing working machines in the trash simply because they are scratched or fail to keep pace with fashion is wasteful vanity.