Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by orthecreedence 3833 days ago
> It sickens me that I have to pay taxes to support them when they just continue to spiral downward.

This is a feedback loop. I'm not saying that throwing more money at public schools will help them get better, but taking money away will certainly make them worse.

> Most liberal solutions that I've seen leave out human nature and a history of complete failure and re-dress it as something 'new'.

Actually agree. Most liberal policies are somewhat naive. But on the other end you have the free market people crowing about benefits of deregulation and wanting to disassemble public services because "I don't want my tax dollars going to [parks, buses, schools, etc etc] I don't even use!!"

There's a medium ground here. The point of society isn't to preserve your tax dollars or to give everyone welfare. The point is that when we all live together as a group, we all do a lot better than we did when it was six of us in a group starving out on the tundra.

There are some public services that we just shouldn't live without, especially if we want to stay competitive as a country. However, some of them need complete overhauls or just shouldn't exist in the first place.

1 comments

I agree with you here. We shouldn't be taking away money from our public school systems. We should be fixing the current situation and making people accountable for the wasted money.

My parents grew up near detroit and they told me about how the state poured money into the school system for years.

They are now some of the worst in the nation, with abysmal graduation rates.

How much did they pay into the public schools? Did they spend as much as public schools around the Washington DC area (best in the country?) And, how much was it compared to what they would pay to private schools?

Yah they didn't pay enough into the system.

A real system is a lot more expensive than what they think.

The solution to the education problem is: spend more money.

See: detroit. 5x was spent for 30 years until the entire system collapsed when enough tax payers fled the city.

This is the result of your plan.