Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rcarmo 3835 days ago
Very neat. Static site generators are hard to get right (I've been hacking away at a hybrid solution at http://sushy.no-bolso.com / http://blog.carmo.io - same engine, different themes).

I do have two questions, though. Why the new file extension (.lr) and the field separator?

Jekyll's front matter format is easier for most people - and my engine uses a plain newline to separate front matter from text, and supports multiple file extensions to make it easier for desktop editors.
2 comments
the_mitsuhiko 3835 days ago
The .lr format is easy to explain: it conforms to data models and is easy to parse and generate. Frontmatter does not fit into these requiements. I tried it quite a bit but it makes everything more complex. Not worth it.
link
rcarmo 3835 days ago
Well (and this is only an opinion) having to separate each field makes it harder to edit manually, and a new file extension will be a hassle for non-technical users who want to use their favorite editor.

(I went with .txt/.md/.textile to support multiple markup engines and make it easier for people to edit with literally anything)

link
the_mitsuhiko 3835 days ago
> Well (and this is only an opinion) having to separate each field makes it harder to edit manually, and a new file extension will be a hassle for non-technical users who want to use their favorite editor.

A non technical user would use the admin interface.

Obviously a custom file extension is not particularly nice but there is really not that much one can do around that. Renaming the file to `.md` will not magically make things better because the contents are just wrong and the Markdown format just does not do what Lektor needs.

link
currysausage 3835 days ago
> Why the new file extension (.lr) and the field separator?

This made me chuckle. Many comments seem to fall into two categories: 1) How is it different from SSG_X? 2) Why is it different from SSG_X? (Both are valid questions, no doubt.)

The flexibility in content structure is what makes Lektor a more framework-like CMS. The possible complexity can't really be represented with newlines. For example, my "Abstract" field might be several paragraphs long.

link