[apag]

Good comment. I just want to react to the last sentence.

I use `git commit -a` plenty and without compunction. There are many times where a tweak or very simple feature doesn’t involve any exploration, and in those cases I rarely need the elaborate staging dance to make a sensible commit. I review the patch and find there is no need to break it down… why go through the index in that case?

The index is just a tool, and so is `-a`. Judge their use, not the tools themselves.

(Of course, sometimes I realise belatedly that a simple feature commit is not as straightforward as it seemed. Well, it would be belated if we weren’t talking about git. Rebasing (interactively, in particular) saves the day in that case. Once again: git goes out of its way to get out of mine. This is really the central point.)