[Retra]

The real question is what does it matter to you? Nothing a person says is correct just because they have the right title or label.

[mikeash]

Speaking only for myself, obviously, I don't find the argument itself to be particularly interesting, but I do find it interesting to find a Brazilian judge posting it on HN, just because that's really unexpected to me. If it's all fake, then the comment ceases to be interesting at all.

[AndrewKemendo]

If the goal is to simply make a compelling argument then stating your title immediately induces bias.

[Retra]

My point is that you have nothing to gain by calling into question the title. You give people the benefit of the doubt because that's the way to maintain civil discourse.