Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jacquesm 3844 days ago
> First time I've read something by you I completely disagree with.

That's scary. Well, there is a first time for everything.

> Simply stating that they are upholding the law of the country, which WhatsApp decided to ignore.

Have a read:

https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2014/country-chapters/brazi...

Brazil is not exactly a paragon of virtue when it comes to police force and legal affairs. Let's give the GGP a free pass for being entirely of 'good intentions', that still leaves you with a police apparatus that is involved in, amongst other things, unlawful killings and the use of torture, they rank 69th on the world corruption index, roughly around the region of such examples of upstanding morality with the authorities of Bulgaria, Romania, Greece and Italy.

If this were North-Korea or China everybody would be cheering on Whatsapp and FB for making a stand and not cooperating with the authorities.

Companies can make it easy on themselves by avoiding hard choices on which regimes to support in their quest for wire-tapping and which not by not having a footprint in a jurisdiction where such abuses are common and at the same time make it has hard as possible technically to actually cooperate in the first place. What you can't do you also can't be compelled to do.

The people of Brazil then have the option to make the use of such software illegal or not.

1 comments

Most of the numbers about brazilian police are totally out of place and don't count the way our country is right now about violence.

We got the highest homicide count on the planet, being a country that banned guns. That, for sure, makes police more agressive.

How can those numbers be 'out of place'? Just last month the state of São Paulo started to remove assassinations by the police from the official murder stats [1] to make it look like things are getting better.

Also:

"Between January and November in 2014, 816 people were murdered by military police officers in the state of São Paulo." - and it did not reduce crime [2]

[1] http://www1.folha.uol.com.br/cotidiano/2015/11/1704292-morte...

[2] http://ponte.org/pm-de-sp-bate-recorde-de-mortes-e-nao-reduz...

Do you realize we got a civil war in Brazil, where 60k people die every year?
It's the media like CNN that make my blood boil. I am not sure why Trump is in every other story on the international channel. Actual reporting does not sell.