Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tptacek 3844 days ago
That's probably not a fair criticism. This is reporting about an extremely famous cryptographer pointing his finger at other cryptographers.

Here's more about it:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10657540

1 comments

Thanks for that pointer. I agree with GP's criticism, though, at least the way the article is written. I was trying to understand it through the lens of the nuclear analogy and failing drastically, because whereas those scientists were developing PRO-nuclear technology, these ones are (a priori, to first order) developing ANTI-surveillance technology.
The nuclear analogy is a little odd, given that one of the reasons we don't have even more nuclear weapons / more states with nuclear weapons / nuclear weapons out in the wild is not technological... but because of international treaties and enforcement.
Rogaway's paper starts with an extended discussion of the role of scientists in the nuclear arms race.