Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chrisrxth 3844 days ago
We chose L-Theanine because it has an excellent safety record, is well studied, and has no known toxic dose. We are very aware of safety and ethics. There are many nootropics and supplement companies safely distributing the same L-Theanine.

While we work through our protocol we will continue to dive into ethics and safety.

3 comments

What you have stated here you have stated in your previous thread announcing doubleblind and presumably elsewhere. I don't have an issue with what you are choosing, or why. In fact, it doesn't really matter.

What matters is that you have a clear and transparent ethics approval process, that you clearly state the steps your protocol had been through, and preferably that you submit your protocol to a human ethics review board, and identify that process openly and transparently.

It sounds like you have already developed your protocol, since you are offering your product for sale shipping from the start of this month. So have you written an ethics proposal? Have you considered submitting it to a HERC? Or are you 'continuing to dive into ethics and safety' now that you have been 'reminded of the importance' of it?

Don't get me wrong, I think your idea and platform is potentially great. But it really seems that you haven't thought about this, and now you're trying to scramble?

If you don't have a science background and aren't partnering with anyone who is, I'd be more than happy to lend my 2c outside of this thread (see profile). Otherwise, I wish you every success with a full and detailed examination of your ethics approach. Medical research (which you are conducting by calling your product an experiment) has a poor history when it comes to blurring the lines between researcher and pharmaceutical company/monetisation, of which you could be said to be doing both at the moment.

    [L-Theanine] has no known toxic dose.
You keep saying this like it means something. Even _water_ has a toxic dose:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1770067/

It really makes me wonder whether you have adequate human subject protections in place or if you just hand-waved those away by assuming L-Theanine was completely safe.

   While we work through our protocol we will continue to dive into ethics and safety.
This part, for what it's worth, is ass backwards.