Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hatmatrix 3858 days ago
Maybe I'm an FP snob but it would have been nice to mention the analogy to set builder notation (though lists aren't sets - maybe multisets or bags) to indicate the existence of higher abstraction; not just syntactic sugar on the for-loop.

However, from a practical point of view I think it is great introduction for procedural programmers to begin using list comprehensions.

2 comments

> though lists aren't sets - maybe multisets or bags

arrays/lists (like maps/hashes, though with a more narrow restriction on the indices) are (or at least are isomorphic to) sets of pairs of (index, element).

They carry information about order which does not exist in multisets/bags.

collections.Counter was designed with multiset in mind.