Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kazinator 3859 days ago
There are ways forward. For instance, instead of a small number of tools which mutate their state, why not let the user clone variants of the tools which are configured differently.

Let me configure two or more copies of the move tool, one configured for layers and one for selections. Let me give them different icons and let me position it in a custom toolbox.

Don't make me do the equivalent of swapping bits on a multi-bit screwdriver. I'm not a mobile handyman trying to save space and weight in a portable toolbox; I can afford to replicate the handle and shaft for each bit.
2 comments
chongli 3858 days ago
The gimp already has this feature. It's called presets and it works well enough. Just set up your tool exactly the way you want it and then save a preset. You can even configure the preset so some settings (such as colour) pass through the preset.
link
kazinator 3858 days ago
If it exists in the version I'm using, it is certainly not discoverable. I don't see any hint of this in a two-level-deep manual search of various menus. I would expect to find osmething like this if I right click on the toolbox (context menu pops up, with one of the choices being "Add New Preset ..." or whatever). Or in the Tools menu, with a menu item being "Manage presets ..." or whatever.

Ah, finally found it. You have to click on the little docking triangle on some specific Tool Options dialog for a given tool. It is in this docking-related menu that a command is found to bring up the Tool Options Menu! I think I didn't notice it before because it's totally "off topic" for docking. (Why would a semantically important feature be found under a little docking triangle?) It is this Tool Options Menu which has the preset management commands.

If you right click anywhere on the Tool Options, you get context menu with one-button context menu which says "Tool Options". When you click that button, it just disappears: there you are in Tool Options as before! Right clicking on a Tool Options object would be the obvious place to have the Tool Options Menu. Then the preset stuff would be more discoverable.

link
vinceguidry 3859 days ago
Not the point. Obviously we can think about ways to avoid each specific problem that each user might have. But developer resources are limited and you can't chase all user's problems.

If you want this worked on, you should contribute to the project. Not saying you need to learn how to actually code on Gimp, but just to add your voice to the mix.

link