Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by happy4crazy 3857 days ago
I like to think of a functor/applicative/monad f a as being "more or less" an a.

For example, take a list of Strings. It's "more or less" a single string, it just hasn't made up its mind yet :) When you say fmap reverse myStrings, you're saying: yeah yeah, I know my string hasn't made up its mind yet, but just reverse it. So you reverse all the possibilities. When you say

  (++) <$> myStrings <*> yourStrings
you're saying: yeah yeah, I know my string hasn't made up its mind yet, and neither has your string, but just concatenate them. So you concatenate all the pairwise possibilities. The monad stuff says you can do control flow: (yeah yeah), but if my string is this long, and your string is a palindrome...

Promises: A Promise Int isn't an Int, but eh, it's more or less an Int. Just as you can add 1 to a regular Int, you can fmap (+1) promisedInt. Just as you can replicate 3 'a' to get "aaa", you can

  replicate <$> promisedInt <*> promisedChar
to promise some repetitive String. (And presumably promisedInt and promisedChar will resolve themselves in parallel!) The monad stuff: if this promised Int ends up being prime, then...

Parsers: A Parser Int (something that can gobble up a string and produce an Int) isn't an Int, but (in some contexts, if it's helpful) you can think of it as being more or less an Int. Saying fmap (+1) intParser says make a parser that parses whatever intParser does, and then adds 1 to the result. Doing

  replicate <$> intParser <*> charParser
makes a parser that tries to parse an Int, and then a Char, and then gives you a repetitive String. Monad stuff: if I parse a prime number, then...

Functions that take some fixed argument type, say Float. A Float -> String isn't a String, obviously, but it's more or less a String :) It's just missing a Float. If I say fmap reverse justNeedAFloatToBeAString, I'm making a new function will take a float and then reverse whatever you get by feeding it to justNeedAFloatToBeAString. If I

  (++) <$> almostAString <*> almostAnotherString,
I'm making a new function of type Float -> String that feeds a Float (the same Float) to both subcomputations and then concatenates their results. Monad stuff: if this almost-Int ends up being prime...

Functor says you can treat a single f a as more or less a single regular a. Applicative says you can treat any number of f a values as more or less any number of regular a values. Monad says you can do control flow with f a values as if they were regular a values.