Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jrnvs 3863 days ago
In Germany your arguably "lower" income comes with healthcare, unemployment insurance and pension rights, which probably makes up for the difference.
2 comments

That doesn't mean much, the educated professional upper middle class in the US earns more and has vastly more disposable income after taxes even when you count the costs of healthcare and personal savings.

And it's not like if you are living in Europe you won't have those expenses I lived in the Netherlands and now living in the UK and in both countries I still pay for private insurance because it covers much more and makes life so much easier for quality of life and preventative treatment. The NHS is great if I get stabbed and need ER or if I get cancer and need treatment for decades but if I want to see an orthopedist or get good dental hell no...

The US also has lower overall COL, considerably cheaper housing (don't bring the Valley up please), cheaper food, cheaper consumer goods, combine that with higher wages especially in highly sought after professions and you get an overall better deal.

I have a coworker living and working in Berlin. He won't stop raving about how cheap it is to live nicely there. He's constantly trying to recruit me to move. I think US companies must just pay more.
Berlin isn't that expensive as far as Germany goes, it was considered a "shithole" for over a decade post unification, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and even Hamburg are considerably more expensive If you come from the "valley" yes Germany will look cheaper especially if you are planning to rent, but then you'll find out that even a tiny 2 bed (500-600 sq/f) in Berlin in anything that's not a low income project that looks like the backdrop set to the Wire will cost you 250-300K EUR and the prices go up from there, if you want a home that is comparable to US sizes 1600-1800 sq/ft which will be very large 3.5-4 bed in Berlin you'll have to say goodbye to 800-1M EUR. The average dev salary in Berlin will be about 40-50K EUR, your friend might be very special and he gets much more and everything looks rosy but it's not the common case. Now don't get me wrong you won't feel "poor" earning 40-50K in Berlin but you won't see nearly as much disposable income as one would in the US. I earn about 100K GBP living in London and while I won't call myself poor I won't even begin to compare myself to friends living in the US making comparable or even lower galleries. The disposable income after tax is absurdly different, and the expenses in the UK and London specifically are several times higher on everything including rent even when comparing to valley prices. Europe is quite good for lower middle class, and it's very very good for old money, but allot of absurdly bloated costs make it harder for people to actually advance in life, especially when their jobs demand or require a certain life style which comes at a premium.
100k pound is very good salary in UK, even in London. That's more than most London GP makes.

How do people in London afford to live there?

By spending sometimes 80% or more of their post tax income on rent. I'm lucky and spend only about half, not remotely broke but will never be able to buy in London either. In the us a similar income would get you a nice house, a pool and even a tesla, in the uk a Prius plugin will cost nearly half of my yearly post tax income and a 2 bed where I live is about 10-12 years of post tax wages.
> In the us a similar income would get you a nice house, a pool and even a tesla

In a comparable place in the US (i.e. NYC) a similar income gets you similar housing - and not much more in food/services.

If you go out into the boonies, yes US housing is cheap but so is the UK. And in both places few people manage to earn six figures outside the bubbles of NYC, Boston and SF/Valley (nationwide, $100k is 92nd percentile of income give or take).

It makes up for some of it, but definitely not all. Rich Americans are the richest.