Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vonklaus 3866 days ago
Paul Graham says this often, and I am paraphrasing here:

They did a study at harvard, and they figured out that MBA's flock to the wrong industry right before it dies. It was bonds, equities and then silicon valley in the 90s.

It was an interesting anecdote which I have heard often, but now am certainly curious enough to try and dig up that article/study.

edit: The author seems like an accomplished person, and I don't want to paint in the tech v. finance differences, but to highlight what camp she is from, take a look at the first sentence describing Mor Assia:

Mor advised Israel’s global telecommunications billing giant, Amdocs, to choose the right verticals for diversification in their technology acquisitions and launched offerings like Billing for Dynamic Pricing to create new growth opportunities.[0]

I mean, sure, I parse JSON data to codify the new web standard leveraging agile tooling like visual basic to fast-follow with a GUI interface which is deployed into our cloud based infrastructure to track the IP address, but I wouldn't write that down in the 2nd sentence of my biography.

[0]https://www.iangels.co/team/mor-assia/

edit: I can not find the video clip. My memory is that the study was done by Harvard Business School, and it found that MBAs were categorically picking the wrong industry. The examples cited by the speaker, I am 90+% confident it was pg restating it, were going to wall street to trade bonds with Michael Milliken right before he went to jail, Silicon Valley right before the bubble burst and one other which I would guess to be real estate or M & A post KKR, but that is just complete conjecture. Don't take my word for it, and I don't want to misquote PG quoting some study, but I am fairly confident for what it is worth.

2 comments

Marc Andreessen: “A very large number of people came out of investment banking, came to Silicon Valley in 1999, cause they thought they were gonna make a lot of money, and in 2001 they all turned around went back to New York and created the credit crisis.” http://ecorner.stanford.edu/authorMaterialInfo.html?mid=2373
Can you please provide source for what you say pg said?
been looking. It is in a video, so it has been difficult all searches of Harvard MBA study pull up Michael O'Church rants. Will update when found.
Just found that rant too!

I remember him saying Business Schools are good at making MBAs that help you run a business well. They should do that and leave cultivating entrepreneurship to folks like YC. But I see that argument in line with this article's data. These MBAs are trained to get things like M&A right, so getting them onboard might be the right thing to do and does not necessarily indicate another crash.

No way can I parse 10 hours of PG video. Just rewatched the Calacanis interview and some of Charlie Rose. I vividly remember him speaking about the study, but can't remember if it was an interview or just a speaking engagement (possibly Pycon 08).

Here is him talking about MBA's whipping their meek rent-a-programmers during the interview[0] which is the best I can do. If anyone remembers what video it is in, or better yet, actually knows the (i believe harvard business school) study, would be super interested.

[0]https://youtu.be/YMqgiXLjvRs?t=20m30s