Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dTal 3875 days ago
>it's kind of funny that skeptics like to dismiss impressive sounding treatments as being placebos. A placebo is a pretty impressive phenomenon!

It's not about whether a treatment works at all - it's about whether it works better than any old random thing. If it doesn't, you can hardly call it a treatment. Sure you could go "hallelujah, a new medicine!" when you find that a sugar pill provides a slight improvement, just like sand pills and empty pills and homeopathy. But you haven't actually discovered anything new.

1 comments

> But you haven't actually discovered anything new.

The fact that sugar pills work may not be new, but it's still pretty remarkable.

It may be remarkable. But it is not a property of the sugar pills.