Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thaumasiotes 3874 days ago
You're agreeing with me. Where "them" is the family of Indo-European languages, the claim "of all of them, English is the only one that doesn't assign genders that way" is false, and is not qualified with the word "almost".

Where "them" is the special-pleading-based group of Indo-European languages currently spoken within "Europe", the claim is less false than otherwise (but still not great), and it's still not qualified with the word "almost".

1 comments

Yeah, i misunderstood you a little. Nevertheless your initial complaint is mistaken.

Honestly, this is a nice example of attribution of responsibility in message comprehension. As a professor he constructs elaborate structures to convey meaning and puts the responsibility to understand on the reader. As an internet commentor you put the responsibility to express himself clearly on him.

You considered it ridiculous that he may have meant "European" languages, but he clearly constructed the group out of those.