Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tajano 3886 days ago
> You may say whatever you like, provided no one is there to hear it.

Freedom of speech does not mean you are granted unmitigated control over the content a private medium, channel, or platform. For example, it doesn't imply that I can force the New York Times to publish this comment in their newspaper, nor can I force NBC to read this comment aloud on the nightly news. Similarly, I cannot force Apple to publish my content on their platform. In no way does this violate of my freedom of speech.

1 comments

>Similarly, I cannot force Apple to publish my content on their platform. In no way does this violate of my freedom of speech.

Only in the sense that this "freedom of speech" is codified in current law -- and that's specific to the US even, elsewhere can differ.

Other countries for examples don't allow a shop owner discriminate as to who he choses to do business with (e.g. like that Colorado bakery that refused to sell to gay couples).

I'd say it would be good for society if companies having mass business platforms were forced by law to not be allowed to censor anything not already censorable by law already (e.g. child pornography, libel etc).