Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by onion2k 3904 days ago
IMHO positive discrimination might only reinforce those prejudices. "Haha, look at those women, they need a head start!" "Damm, women are so weak they need lower standards to join the firefighters." "Women need their own separate tournaments because they couldn't even face the worst male team." All things I heard.

Which is why, as an enlightened and intelligent person, when you hear things like that it's your job to point out that the positive discrimination is only necessary because of the negative attitudes people have towards minority groups. All the remarks you heard are examples of negative, sexist discrimination. We should all be willing to speak out against it, and all work to resolve the issue of inequality. And that includes defending positive discrimination for the good it does.

1 comments

Did you read the rest of my comment?

> And that includes defending positive discrimination for the good it does.

Does it? I feel you think that's an axiom. Is it? You didn't argue why, and it's the crux of my comment: if it does good or not. I'm not convinced it does good (or bad), but you seem so convinced I hoped you could answer my comment instead of reinstating how good you think positive discrimination is.

I'll quote myself:

> How are we going to get rid of the biological discrimination, to then then get rid of the positive discrimination? I don't think we can. I think we just have to accept it and normalize it and be fine with each person having different aptitudes and traits.

I invite you to read my comment carefully and reflect on it. IMHO it's not an issue as simple as you seem to think it is. And if it is, please enlighten me (I'm genuinely open to it!)