Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by j_syk 3905 days ago
So my hobbies of homebrewing (88k alcohol related deaths), motorcycle riding (5k), and driving cars(22k) should all be banned?
2 comments

88k alcohol "related" deaths is a suspicious number, but the other two require permits and licensure with mandated learning periods and an in-person demonstration that you can safely handle the vehicle. Gun regulations vary from state to state, and such a requirement is not present nationwide.
Alcohol, motorcycle, and vehicle regulations also vary state-to-state. There are examples of operating a motorcycle and/or vehicle without a state license is allowed. You are required to have a license to operate the vehicle on public roads, for instance. Many states have similar regulations on carrying a weapon in public, versus having a gun only in your house. These states usually have similar requirements of training and demonstration of proficiency before granting a carry license. Although I've never heard of insurance for such a thing, but it wouldn't be a bad idea.
I said "murder". That is, intentional killing of another human being.
Do you know how many sport shooters or hunters are involved in murders? (legitimate question)

While the situation in the US is bad, I don't think a straight ban is the answer. It's definitely complicated.

> Do you know how many sport shooters or hunters are involved in murders? (legitimate question)

No, and I don't understand the relevance.

> While the situation in the US is bad, I don't think a straight ban is the answer. It's definitely complicated.

It is indeed complicated, but it's pretty clear that the status quo isn't the answer either.

The first question is in reference to your original statement of "find a new hobby". I'm using that to say that target shooting or hunting are hobbies. Whereas owning a gun for "safety" or "being cool" is not a hobby. And my speculation is that the latter group of gun owners is more of the problem.
I think limiting gun ownership to the former group would be a reasonable compromise ;)
That's not what murder is.